Key Takeaways
- The HGB requires every Kapitalgesellschaft (corporation) to prepare annual financial statements (Jahresabschluss) comprising a balance sheet, profit and loss account, and notes.
- Since April 2024, the §267 size thresholds have been raised by 25%, pushing the small-company ceiling to EUR 7.5M balance sheet total and EUR 15M revenue.
- Only medium-sized and large corporations face a mandatory statutory audit under HGB §316; small corporations are exempt.
- Misclassifying company size under §267 can trigger either an unnecessary audit or an illegal omission of one.
What is HGB (Handelsgesetzbuch / German Commercial Code)?
The HGB's Third Book governs the financial reporting obligations of all merchants (Kaufleute) registered in the Handelsregister. For sole traders and partnerships, HGB §§238–263 set baseline bookkeeping and annual accounts requirements. For corporations (GmbH, AG, KGaA) and certain partnerships with no natural person as general partner (GmbH & Co. KG), the supplementary rules in HGB §§264–335c apply. These supplementary rules implement EU Directive 2013/34/EU and impose tiered disclosure, filing, and audit obligations based on company size.
HGB §267 classifies corporations into four categories: micro, small, medium, and large. Classification depends on whether the entity exceeds two of three thresholds (balance sheet total, revenue, average employees) on two consecutive balance sheet dates. HGB §316.1 makes the statutory audit mandatory for medium-sized and large corporations. The Wirtschaftsprüfer (German auditor) conducts the audit under HGB §317 and issues the Bestätigungsvermerk (auditor's report). Small corporations file abbreviated financial statements with the Bundesanzeiger (Federal Gazette) and face no audit requirement, a distinction that makes the §267 classification decision one of the highest-stakes annual compliance judgments in German practice.
Worked example: Hoffmann Maschinenbau GmbH
Client: German engineering company, FY2025, revenue EUR 28M, HGB reporter. Hoffmann has 180 employees and a balance sheet total of EUR 18M.
Step 1 — Classify the entity under HGB §267
The engagement partner applies the three §267 thresholds for medium-sized corporations (after the April 2024 increase): balance sheet total exceeding EUR 7.5M, revenue exceeding EUR 15M, average employees exceeding 50. Hoffmann exceeds all three. It exceeded the same thresholds in FY2024. The entity qualifies as medium-sized under §267.2 because it exceeds two of three criteria on two consecutive balance sheet dates.
Step 2 — Confirm audit obligation and scope
Because Hoffmann is medium-sized, HGB §316.1 requires a statutory audit of the Jahresabschluss and the Lagebericht (management report). The engagement partner confirms that the firm holds a WPK registration and that the signing Wirtschaftsprüfer satisfies the independence requirements under §319 HGB. The audit follows the IDW Prüfungsstandards, which incorporate ISA into German practice.
Step 3 — Apply HGB recognition and measurement rules
Hoffmann capitalised EUR 1.4M of development costs for a new CNC machine prototype. HGB §248.2 permits (but does not require) capitalisation of internally generated intangible assets, unlike IFRS where IAS 38 requires capitalisation when criteria are met. The engagement team verifies that Hoffmann's accounting policy elects capitalisation under §248.2 and that the corresponding distribution restriction under §268.8 has been applied (blocking dividend distribution up to the carrying amount of the capitalised development costs less associated deferred tax liabilities).
Step 4 — Verify filing with the Bundesanzeiger
After issuing the Bestätigungsvermerk, the engagement partner reminds Hoffmann's management that HGB §325 requires publication of the annual financial statements in the Bundesanzeiger within 12 months of the balance sheet date. Medium-sized corporations may use the disclosure simplifications under §327a (omitting the profit and loss account from the published version) but must file the full set with the Unternehmensregister.
Conclusion: the engagement file is defensible because it traces the classification decision from §267 through the audit obligation under §316, applies HGB-specific recognition rules (§248.2 capitalisation option with §268.8 distribution lock), and documents the filing requirements under §325.
Why it matters in practice
The April 2024 threshold increase under the Zweites Gesetz zur Änderung des DWD-Gesetzes created a one-time reclassification opportunity. Practitioners at smaller firms frequently apply the new thresholds without verifying the two-consecutive-years rule in §267.4. A corporation that exceeded the old thresholds in FY2023 but falls below the new thresholds in FY2024 does not automatically reclassify; it must fall below the new thresholds on two consecutive balance sheet dates before the reduced obligations apply.
German practitioners sometimes treat the §248.2 option to capitalise internally generated intangible assets as a free accounting policy choice without documenting the §268.8 distribution restriction. The restriction requires that dividends cannot be distributed to the extent of the carrying amount of capitalised development costs (net of associated deferred tax liabilities under §274). Auditors who test the capitalised asset but skip the §268.8 dividend lock leave a gap that WPK peer reviewers flag.
HGB vs. IFRS
| Dimension | HGB | IFRS |
|---|---|---|
| Governing principle | Vorsichtsprinzip (prudence principle) under §252.1 Nr. 4: assets and profits must not be overstated | Fair presentation under IAS 1.15: financial statements must present a true and fair view of economic reality |
| Internally generated intangibles | §248.2 permits capitalisation (option), with §268.8 distribution restriction | IAS 38.57 requires capitalisation when recognition criteria are met |
| Revenue recognition | §252.1 Nr. 4 (realisation principle): revenue recognised when performance risk transfers | IFRS 15: revenue recognised when control of the performance obligation transfers to the customer |
| Scope in Germany | Mandatory for Einzelabschluss of all corporations; basis for tax and distributions | Mandatory for consolidated statements of capital-market-oriented entities under §315e; voluntary for others |
The distinction matters when auditing a German group that prepares IFRS consolidated statements but HGB individual accounts. The auditor must apply HGB recognition and measurement rules to the Einzelabschluss (which determines distributable profits and the tax base) while applying IFRS to the consolidated package. Mixing the two frameworks in the wrong direction produces financial statements that are neither HGB-compliant nor IFRS-compliant.
Related terms
Frequently asked questions
Does HGB apply if a German company reports under IFRS?
HGB still applies to the individual entity financial statements (Einzelabschluss) for tax and distribution purposes even when the group prepares consolidated statements under IFRS. HGB §325.2a permits a company to publish IFRS consolidated financial statements in place of HGB consolidated statements, but the statutory Einzelabschluss under HGB remains the basis for determining distributable profits per §268.8 and the tax base per §5.1 EStG.
What are the HGB size thresholds after the 2024 amendment?
Since April 2024, small corporations must not exceed two of three limits: €7.5M balance sheet total, €15M revenue, 50 employees. Medium-sized corporations must not exceed two of three limits: €25M balance sheet total, €50M revenue, 250 employees. Entities exceeding the medium thresholds on two consecutive balance sheet dates are classified as large under HGB §267.3. The employee threshold was not changed; only the monetary amounts increased by approximately 25%.
When must the Jahresabschluss be filed with the Bundesanzeiger?
HGB §325.1a requires corporations to file annual financial statements with the Bundesanzeiger within 12 months of the balance sheet date. For publicly traded companies, the deadline is four months per §325.4 in conjunction with the WpHG. The Bundesamt für Justiz can impose Ordnungsgelder (penalty payments) starting at €2,500 for late filing under §335 HGB, and these penalties escalate with continued non-compliance.